How to use this calculator
- Enter Pre-tax contribution ($)。
- Enter Current tax rate (%)。
- Enter Retirement tax rate (%)。
- Enter Annual return (%)。
- Enter Number of years (years)。
Leave any field blank and the calculator solves for it from the remaining values — every quantity is reversible.
The calculator then returns: Roth after-tax value、Traditional after-tax value。
What is it
Roth vs Traditional — Enter Pre-tax contribution, Current tax rate, Retirement tax rate, Annual return and Number of years to get Roth after-tax value and Traditional after-tax value — or leave any field blank to solve for it. Tax calculators apply rates, deductions and depreciation rules to your figures to estimate tax due or after-tax outcomes. The core question it answers is: Roth after-tax value and Traditional after-tax value. With Pre-tax contribution = 10,000 $, Current tax rate = 30 % and Retirement tax rate = 22 %, Roth after-tax value is 37,992 $.
Formula
| Variable | Inputs | Unit |
|---|---|---|
contribution | Pre-tax contribution | $ |
currentRate | Current tax rate | % |
retireRate | Retirement tax rate | % |
annualRate | Annual return | % |
years | Number of years | years |
rothValue | Roth after-tax value | $ |
tradValue | Traditional after-tax value | $ |
contribution * (1 - currentRate / 100) * Math.pow(1 + annualRate / 100, years)contribution * Math.pow(1 + annualRate / 100, years) * (1 - retireRate / 100)The relationship is solved in every direction, so any one unknown field can be derived.
Worked example
Using the default inputs:
- Pre-tax contribution = 10000 $
- Current tax rate = 30 %
- Retirement tax rate = 22 %
- Annual return = 7 %
- Number of years = 25 years
Formula used: contribution * (1 - currentRate / 100) * Math.pow(1 + annualRate / 100, years)
Answer:
- Roth after-tax value = 37,992.03 $
- Traditional after-tax value = 42,333.97 $
Example 1 (default inputs):Suppose Pre-tax contribution = 10,000 $, Current tax rate = 30 %, Retirement tax rate = 22 %, Annual return = 7 %, Number of years = 25 years; then giving Roth after-tax value = 37,992 $, Traditional after-tax value = 42,334 $.
Example 2 (one input changed):If you change Pre-tax contribution to 15,000,giving Roth after-tax value = 56,988 $, Traditional after-tax value = 63,501 $.
Additional information
Assumptions and limitations
- Tax systems are highly local and change often: allowances, brackets, social contributions and surtaxes differ by jurisdiction. These calculators return a mechanical result from your inputs — for filings, rely on your tax authority and a professional.
- Good for: getting a directionally correct order of magnitude quickly, or comparing two scenarios.
- Not good for: using it as the sole basis for a decision, or for official filings, contract pricing and legal documents — those need a full model with your actual clauses and local rules.