How to use this calculator
- Enter Initial investment ($)。
- Enter Index fund annual return (%)。
- Enter Active fund annual return (%)。
- Enter Holding years (years)。
Leave any field blank and the calculator solves for it from the remaining values — every quantity is reversible.
The calculator then returns: Index fund final value、Active fund final value、Index fund advantage。
What is it
Index vs Mutual Fund — Enter Initial investment, Index fund annual return, Active fund annual return and Holding years to get Index fund final value, Active fund final value and Index fund advantage — or leave any field blank to solve for it. Investment calculators quantify the time value of money, returns and risk, turning a vague sense of "this will do well" into comparable numbers. The core question it answers is: Index fund final value, Active fund final value and Index fund advantage. With Initial investment = 100,000 $, Index fund annual return = 7 % and Active fund annual return = 6.5 %, Index fund final value is 275,903 $.
Formula
| Variable | Inputs | Unit |
|---|---|---|
initialAmount | Initial investment | $ |
indexReturn | Index fund annual return | % |
mutualReturn | Active fund annual return | % |
years | Holding years | years |
indexValue | Index fund final value | $ |
mutualValue | Active fund final value | $ |
outperformance | Index fund advantage | $ |
initialAmount*Math.pow(1+indexReturn/100,years)initialAmount*Math.pow(1+mutualReturn/100,years)indexValue - mutualValueThe relationship is solved in every direction, so any one unknown field can be derived.
Worked example
Using the default inputs:
- Initial investment = 100000 $
- Index fund annual return = 7 %
- Active fund annual return = 6.5 %
- Holding years = 15 years
Formula used: initialAmount*Math.pow(1+indexReturn/100,years)
Answer:
- Index fund final value = 275,903.15 $
- Active fund final value = 257,184.1 $
- Index fund advantage = 18,719.05 $
Example 1 (default inputs):Suppose Initial investment = 100,000 $, Index fund annual return = 7 %, Active fund annual return = 6.5 %, Holding years = 15 years; then giving Index fund final value = 275,903 $, Active fund final value = 257,184 $, Index fund advantage = 18,719 $.
Example 2 (one input changed):If you change Initial investment to 150,000,giving Index fund final value = 413,855 $, Active fund final value = 385,776 $, Index fund advantage = 28,079 $.
Additional information
Assumptions and limitations
- These models assume a constant rate, periodic compounding, and no taxes or trading costs. Real return sequences, fees and taxes materially change outcomes — treat results as planning guidance, not a promise.
- Good for: getting a directionally correct order of magnitude quickly, or comparing two scenarios.
- Not good for: using it as the sole basis for a decision, or for official filings, contract pricing and legal documents — those need a full model with your actual clauses and local rules.